Custom Shopify Apps vs Off-the-Shelf: When to Build vs Buy

The Shopify App Store has over 8,000 apps. Chances are, there's already an app that does what you need.

So why would anyone build a custom app?

The answer: when off-the-shelf apps don't fit your unique workflow.

In this guide, we'll help you decide when to buy an existing app and when to invest in custom development.

When to Use Off-the-Shelf Apps

Start here. Off-the-shelf apps are faster, cheaper, and lower-risk for common use cases.

For inspiration on which workflows to automate first, check out our guide on Shopify automation best practices.

✅ Use Off-the-Shelf When:

1. The workflow is standard

• Email marketing (Klaviyo)
• Reviews (Judge.me, Yotpo)
• Loyalty programs (Smile.io)
• Abandoned cart recovery (Privy)

2. You need it now

• Off-the-shelf apps install in minutes from the Shopify App Store
• Custom apps take weeks to build

3. Budget is tight

• Most apps cost $10-$50/month
• Custom apps start at $5k-$10k

4. You're testing an idea

• Use an existing app to validate demand
• Build custom later if it proves valuable

❌ Off-the-Shelf Limitations

• Rigid workflows: You adapt to the app, not the other way around
• Feature bloat: Pay for features you don't need
• Integration gaps: Doesn't connect to your ERP/WMS/3PL
• No competitive advantage: Your competitors use the same app
• Scaling issues: May struggle as you grow (learn more about scaling Shopify operations)

When to Build Custom

Custom apps make sense when your workflow is unique or when off-the-shelf apps create more problems than they solve.

✅ Build Custom When:

1. Your workflow is unique

• Multi-vendor marketplace logic
• Custom pricing rules (tiered, volume-based, customer-specific)
• Specialized fulfillment routing (like bulk delivery updates)
• Industry-specific compliance requirements

2. You need deep integrations

• Sync Shopify with your ERP (NetSuite, SAP, Dynamics) using Shopify's Admin API
• Connect to proprietary systems (WMS, 3PL, custom databases)
• Real-time data exchange with external APIs via webhooks

3. Off-the-shelf apps don't scale

• You've outgrown the app's limits (order volume, SKU count)
• Performance issues with large catalogs
• Need custom reporting and analytics beyond Shopify's built-in reports

4. You want a competitive advantage

• Build something your competitors can't replicate
• Create a unique customer experience
• Automate proprietary processes

Understanding the hidden cost of manual processes can help justify custom automation investments.

💰 Cost Comparison

Scenario	Off-the-Shelf	Custom App
Simple workflow	$20/month	$5k-$10k upfront
Complex workflow	$200/month + workarounds	$10k-$25k upfront
Integration	Often not possible	$15k-$30k
Ongoing costs	Monthly subscription	Maintenance ($500-$2k/month)

The Hybrid Approach

You don't have to choose one or the other. Many successful stores use a mix:

• Off-the-shelf for common tasks: Email, reviews, chat
• Custom for unique workflows: Order routing, pricing logic, integrations
• Team augmentation: Consider building a remote ops team to manage both

This gives you speed where it matters and flexibility where you need it.

Decision Framework

Ask yourself these questions:

1. Does an existing app do 80% of what I need?

   • Yes → Use off-the-shelf
   • No → Consider custom

2. Is this workflow a competitive advantage?

   • Yes → Build custom
   • No → Use off-the-shelf

3. Do I need to integrate with external systems?

   • Yes → Likely need custom using Shopify APIs
   • No → Off-the-shelf works

4. What's my timeline?

   • Need it this week → Off-the-shelf
   • Can wait 2-4 weeks → Custom is an option

5. What's my budget?

   • Under $5k → Off-the-shelf
   • Over $10k → Custom is viable

Real-World Examples

Example 1: Multi-Vendor Marketplace

Problem: Shopify doesn't natively support multi-vendor marketplaces. Off-the-Shelf: Apps like Multi Vendor Marketplace exist, but they're rigid and expensive. Custom Solution: Build vendor portals, commission tracking, and payout automation tailored to your business model using Shopify's GraphQL API. Verdict: Build custom.

Example 2: Email Marketing

Problem: Need to send abandoned cart emails. Off-the-Shelf: Klaviyo, Omnisend, Shopify Email. Custom Solution: Build your own email system. Verdict: Use off-the-shelf. Don't reinvent the wheel.

Example 3: ERP Integration

Problem: Sync Shopify orders with NetSuite in real-time. Off-the-Shelf: Generic connectors exist but don't map your custom fields. Custom Solution: Build a tailored integration with error handling and retry logic using Shopify webhooks. Verdict: Build custom.

The Bottom Line

Start with off-the-shelf apps for standard workflows. They're fast, cheap, and proven.

Build custom when:

• Your workflow is unique
• You need deep integrations
• Off-the-shelf apps create more problems than they solve
• You're scaling rapidly and need flexibility

And remember: you can always start with an off-the-shelf app and build custom later when you've validated the need.

Learn more about automating your entire Shopify workflow for maximum efficiency.

---

Thinking about building a custom Shopify app? Check out our Build Studio or request a proposal.